YearsTell

Which model year should you buy?

Owner-filed safety complaints, counted over the same three years of each car’s life and divided by how many were sold. How this is built.

129 nameplates with a verified denominator. The spread within a nameplate is usually far larger than the gap between brands, which is why these are organised by car rather than by badge.

VehicleModel yearsBestWorstSpread
Chrysler Pacifica70.567.4113.1x
Dodge Journey120.096.7677.7x
Chevrolet Bolt EV70.485.9812.5x
Honda HR-V80.105.6557.6x
Jeep Cherokee90.315.6018.3x
Jeep Wrangler160.365.3514.9x
Ford Fiesta90.244.8319.7x
Nissan Pathfinder140.194.8325.0x
Jeep Grand Cherokee160.244.6219.5x
Volkswagen Atlas60.774.576.0x
Honda Civic160.164.3928.2x
Subaru Outback160.304.3014.3x
Dodge Avenger70.143.8427.6x
Chevrolet Volt90.453.467.7x
Cadillac Escalade140.173.4419.9x
Subaru Ascent50.563.436.1x
Ford Edge150.113.4231.0x
Ford Flex110.133.4025.5x
Ford Focus110.133.2925.0x
Volkswagen Jetta160.053.0162.8x
Subaru Forester160.152.9820.2x
Hyundai Sonata160.202.9514.6x
Subaru Legacy150.202.9514.7x
Acura TLX80.372.897.8x
Jeep Renegade80.212.8213.6x
Ford Fusion130.162.7917.9x
Nissan Titan90.342.768.2x
Ford Mustang120.322.748.6x
Ford Explorer160.112.7025.2x
Chrysler Town and Country90.372.607.0x
Volkswagen CC60.202.4912.3x
Fiat 50040.552.484.5x
Honda Passport50.512.364.6x
Dodge Challenger120.172.3313.6x
GMC Acadia160.142.2916.0x
Chevrolet Spark50.232.299.8x
Acura RDX110.192.2812.0x
Honda CR-V160.202.2711.3x
Alfa Romeo Giulia31.092.252.1x
Toyota Corolla160.182.1211.5x
Chrysler 300120.162.1113.3x
Nissan Rogue160.202.0910.7x
Lincoln MKT40.492.034.1x
Genesis G8030.692.032.9x
Ford Escape160.282.037.3x
Alfa Romeo Stelvio20.471.994.3x
Hyundai Santa Fe160.261.977.7x
Chevrolet Suburban150.081.9723.4x
Kia Soul140.231.948.6x
Dodge Charger150.141.9413.8x
Lincoln MKX100.121.9216.1x
Volkswagen Golf90.341.915.6x
Honda Accord160.281.876.7x
Dodge Grand Caravan120.321.875.8x
Kia Sportage150.191.839.5x
Nissan Altima160.101.7818.2x
Honda Odyssey160.121.7014.4x
Mazda CX-5110.191.678.9x
Mitsubishi Outlander80.251.676.6x
Chevrolet Tahoe160.091.6517.5x
Buick Encore110.201.638.2x
Cadillac ATS50.111.5915.0x
Honda Pilot160.101.5916.2x
Volkswagen Touareg60.221.587.2x
Jeep Patriot100.231.576.7x
Lincoln Aviator40.681.562.3x
Hyundai Elantra160.171.539.1x
Ram Promaster100.171.508.9x
Subaru Crosstrek80.131.4510.8x
Acura MDX150.171.438.3x
Nissan Murano120.171.428.5x
Volvo XC4040.791.411.8x
Dodge Ram50.381.393.7x
Buick Enclave140.181.397.8x
Toyota Highlander160.281.374.9x
GMC Sierra160.131.3310.1x
Volvo XC60110.051.3125.8x
Ram Pickup110.401.313.3x
Lincoln Nautilus30.111.2911.8x
Ford F-Series160.231.295.6x
Nissan Kicks40.531.292.4x
Acura TSX60.031.2937.8x
Nissan Sentra150.111.2711.6x
Audi Q790.161.258.0x
Subaru Impreza130.141.248.6x
Toyota Tacoma160.151.228.1x
Chevrolet Cruze80.241.215.0x
Acura ILX20.231.215.2x
Kia Niro60.381.203.1x
Infiniti QX5030.301.183.9x
Honda Fit120.111.1610.3x
Mazda CX-9130.091.1213.2x
Mazda Mazda3140.211.125.3x
Ford Taurus110.151.087.0x
Ford Transit80.091.0812.5x
Ford Expedition160.141.067.3x
Toyota Camry160.111.069.8x
Mercedes-Benz GLC60.061.0418.6x
Chevrolet Traverse150.191.035.4x
Buick Regal70.391.012.6x
Cadillac XT530.201.005.0x
Toyota RAV4160.151.006.6x
Chevrolet Camaro100.180.945.2x
Nissan Maxima100.180.915.0x
Mazda Mazda6100.170.895.3x
Kia Forte140.120.846.7x
GMC Terrain140.150.835.6x
Cadillac CTS100.240.833.5x
Chevrolet Equinox160.080.8310.6x
Buick LaCrosse100.090.808.6x
Lincoln Navigator70.180.784.4x
Nissan Juke60.180.754.1x
Kia Rio110.150.744.9x
Buick Envision30.480.731.5x
Acura TL50.140.715.1x
BMW X5150.210.703.4x
Mercedes-Benz GLA 25050.090.708.2x
Volvo S6060.230.672.9x
Mercedes-Benz C30070.070.6610.0x
Chevrolet Silverado160.100.646.2x
Porsche Macan50.220.642.9x
Cadillac XTS20.420.581.4x
Hyundai Accent110.110.585.1x
Nissan 370Z30.230.532.3x
Lexus IS60.140.513.5x
Hyundai Kona60.070.477.1x
Mercedes-Benz E35090.070.476.4x
Land Rover Range Rover50.150.392.5x
Chevrolet Avalanche50.050.325.9x